Skip to main content

Importance of history in affirmative action.


Our education system is based on the ideal that best and the brightest gets the best education and opportunities. This translates into the opposition for affirmative action, as racial prioritization in selection will deny some of the more 'qualified' students their chances of getting the best education they can. While most people agree that the American history plagued with racism has created unequal opportunities in the past, they argue that racism is mostly a thing of past. It's a common to hear people say, "I'm not a racist, nor are my parents, so why do I have to pay for a slavery that happened more than a century ago?". On the other hand, even some liberal minded people seem to think that the situation of minorities today is partly due to their own fault, "it's just that they are not trying hard enough". Hence the question is, almost 40 years after the civil rights movement (ok, 37 years), do we really need to talk about the historical facts that brought about the inequality in the USA? Isn't 40 years enough time to wither off much of the negative effects of racism?

Lets sum up the history that led us up here.

Racial oppression before the end of WWII

Any analysis of historical effects of inequality has to start with slavery. While the white majority advanced through the new world, slavery kept African Americans out of access to any education (or any other opportunity, for that matter) for two centuries. The inhumane oppression of minorities continued for another century in the form of Jim Crow laws after eliminating slavery. While "Jim Crow" laws refer to the de jure segregationist laws in the south, similar laws existed in north and west targeting both black and Asian minorities. Northern states had similar segregationist laws banning blacks from entering to the state, voting, assembling and even testifying against a white in court. For instance Indiana passed a law in 1851 banning blacks entering the northern states and prohibiting whites the employment of those. In California, the minorities faced discrimination at the end of the gold rush era. Both Chinese and Mexicans were targeted in taxing foreign miners and were forbidden from obtaining citizenship, and the racial oppression was evident in many court rulings against Asian and Mexican miners in this era. At the height of these tensions, with the incidents starting from the Chinese massacre in 1871, most Chinese workers and merchants were the targets of physical violence, driving them out of their homes to the newly forming 'China towns'. These ethnic enclaves offered little chance of economic success, as they had to take menial low paying jobs and were not allowed to work outside of the given area. Similar measures were taken later, at the beginning of the great depression, to prevent Mexican Americans and from accessing the scarce economic opportunities. The racial discrimination thus created a vast inequality in access to better paying jobs, and hence economic success of the minorities. Data below shows the disparity in education and socio-economic index (SEI) between the minorities clearly. It should be noted that the Chinese and Japanese are taken as one group, and with Japanese immigrants, who were doing relatively well before the internment in 1942, changes the statistics for this group. Understanding these racial inequalities in early 1940s help better understand the ever widening inequality after the end of WWII.




Years of schooling
Occupational SEI
Native African American
5.4
13.3
Native Mexican American
4.7
14.8
Native American (Native Indian)
5.6
14.8
Native Chinese/Japanese American
9.1
30.1
US Population
8.9
29.5
Native White
9.3
30.8

New middle class social order

The mass rearrangement of the social order in America after the end of the world war II created the conditions for the strong structural racism that persists today. Being the only industrial country in the world that left standing on its feet after the WWII, USA quickly captured the world market through its vast industrial production machine, that was transformed from its original purpose of wartime production. United states became the worlds super power, both economically and politically. Sudden expansion of the US economy was felt positively by people across the income spectrum through the high paying blue collar jobs and the new deal social services. The labor force became increasingly unionized, and they successively won many battles and the workplace standards, wages and benefits of the unionized workers increased dramatically, while G.I bill gave many war veterans access to higher education. All these changes gave most Americans access to middle class

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

White supremacy and russophobia!

Compiled using grok, gemini, chatgpt etc: The evolution of xenophobia against Eastern Europeans in Western Europe, particularly through the lenses of colonial white supremacy and neo-imperialism post-Cold War, is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon rooted in historical, economic, and geopolitical dynamics. This survey note aims to provide a comprehensive analysis, drawing on academic sources and historical evidence to trace the development of these attitudes. Historical Roots: Enlightenment and the Construction of Eastern Europe The intellectual foundations of xenophobia against Eastern Europeans can be traced to the Enlightenment period, as elucidated by Larry Wolff in his seminal work, Inventing Eastern Europe: The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment ( Inventing Eastern Europe: The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment ). Wolff argues that Western European philosophers, viewing the continent from the perspective of Paris, deliberately cultivated t...

Twilight zone: The past ghosts as the rulers of the present

Using the details in a personal note (“The Good Place”) and this grok chat. Not an ideal article, but took few hours compared to weeks... Introduction: Contextualizing the Persistence of Modern Structures In the twilight zone of our present reality, the ghosts of the past continue to rule, their specters haunting the structures of our post-Modern world. Despite the apparent shifts from the modern to the post-Modern era, the deep-seated structures of capitalism, control, and social hierarchies persist, often dressed in the rhetoric of progress and liberation. This article aims to explore how the modern era’s foundational elements have subverted or thrived within the post-Modern context, revealing that the more things change, the more they remain the same. From social structures to religion and spirituality, each dimension of society has been transformed, yet the underlying power dynamics remain remarkably consistent. By examining these dimensions, we can see how the post-Modern e...

Our Collective Needs,

.. cannot be so far that we burn our world and murder our souls! We know we could live in a better world.. Where we all feel more at home, Our bodies nourished; our hearts loved...  Let us hold our future selves. Hold them in our hearts and let them plant the seeds. Seeds that root, and break us free. From the tricksters that trapped us, Out of a machine that enslaves us.  ... a toxic giant, raging, yet breaking, loosing power, but growing hungrier..! Let us step out, gently, to the chaotic, yet purposeful, From the dark that deceives, into the dawn that guides,  To build a world, whose tomorrow is brighter, Everyday!

"There have never been a Revolution without a starving mass"

Politics that advocate taking power is doomed for failure, and toxic, maybe!   In  Snipers in the kitchen ", @MonederoJC examines the failures of the leftist movements across Central and South America. He talks about how centers of power, which are very much intact after a populist leftist movement takes power, align to undermine and defeat the leftist project. "Snipers" he refers to are these institutions; mass media, the judiciary, police/military, and of course, the market forces -- the capital, and their minions, the traps laid in every corner of the house. The 21st century repeats are only a stone's throw away from where ever one is, from Syriza, Corbyn, Chile to maybe whatever the whole left-progressive thing in the US was ? At the end of the day none of these movements garnered enough momentum to make a dent in the power structures that they fought to defeat. I think we are much deeper in 💩 than just not having powerful popular institutions though (i.e The Ma...

Free Will, And the direction of Collapse, The

🚬 was good! But was it? Am I better than? A break, a swim around the lake,  With thoughts, with clouds...  Done better than that, could I have not? ⚠️ But It's all physics, right! ... right? I am but some star-dust. Dead, a long before.. But am I? 🚫 🙊 well what would that 'I' do, Next? This bunch of gore and light! Well, 👆 is all just Physics,  ⚡| ➡️ ? I mean I feel that I am, Like I feel that I choose! But why , you say it weak , when that's  all that I am? But is it. what. I. am? Can 'I' be not, but i be conscious? Can that not be what 'real' freedom is? But would that not be free (the) will, But not be free-will?  So maybe 'I' must exist for free will, but not free will, for i But what do I know of a life without, So pardon me, for the halts,  - by 'I'